This year were writing a series of posts about the ingredients we bake with at the Bakehouse and at BAKE!, our hands on teaching bakery for home bakers. It sounds orderly when I put it like that. In practice it usually begins with someone holding a bag of flour and asking, Why does this one behave differently?
We use traditional recipes, time honored processes, our hands, and ingredients that actually taste like something. One of the key factors in making good bread and pastries is using ingredients with flavor. Perfect execution with flat ingredients may create a loaf that looks impressive, but youll be disappointed when you taste it. You really can taste the difference. I have made the beautiful but bland loaf before. It photographs well. It does not get eaten.
So were starting with Bakers Yeast, the living leavener that gives rise to many of the breads and pastries we make. It is a fungus. That is the simple truth. And yet when you open the oven and see dough lifted and set, it still feels like something close to wonder.
The strain of yeast used in baking, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, is a single celled microorganism from the fungus kingdom. To thrive, Bakers yeast requires food, warmth, and moisture. When warmth and moisture are present, it converts sugars and starches into alcohol and carbon dioxide through fermentation. The carbon dioxide gives breads and pastries their rise. Tiny organisms eat, release gas, and we call it baking. There is something steadying about that.
Humans have been baking with naturally occurring yeast for more than 10,000 years. Ancient Egyptians were using yeast and fermentation to leaven bread. In the mid 19th century, Louis Pasteur identified yeast as a living organism responsible for alcoholic fermentation and dough leavening. It became possible to isolate strains of yeast in pure culture form. Since then, bakers, scientists, and commercial yeast manufacturers have worked to produce strains that meet the needs of the baking industry and the home baker. We are part of a long line of people waiting on dough to rise.
For the home baker, commercial Bakers yeast comes in three forms: Fresh Cake Yeast, Active Dry Yeast, and Instant Yeast. Each behaves slightly differently. Each asks for a slightly different approach.
Fresh cake yeast, also known as wet or compressed yeast, consists of blocks of moist, active yeast cells. Soft and crumbly. It can be crumbled into dry ingredients or softened in warm water first. It works well in breads that require a long, slow rise or fermentation time, as it activates quickly and stays active for long periods. It is the form we use in the Bread Bakery in all of our yeasted, non sourdough breads. The brand we use consistently is Red Star Fresh Cake Yeast.
For the home baker, fresh cake yeast may not be practical. It is perishable. It must be stored in the refrigerator in an airtight container and used quickly, since it only has around a two week shelf life. It can also be difficult to find. You may finally locate it and then forget it in the back of the fridge. It will not wait patiently.
Which is why many home bakers use dry yeast. Active Dry and Instant.
Active dry yeast was developed early in the 20th century and is still widely available. The texture is granular, similar to fine cornmeal. The live but dormant yeast must first be activated by dissolving the granules in warm water, ideally between 105? and 115?. This is blooming. When dissolved, small bubbles rise to the surface. Adding sugar or honey encourages this by giving the yeast immediate carbohydrates before it reaches the flour.
It is straightforward most of the time. But active dry yeast can be inconsistent. Its potency can vary. It helps to check the expiration date and confirm through activation whether the yeast is alive before moving forward. I have skipped that step. The dough did not forgive me.
Instant yeast came of age in the 1970s. It was made simpler to use and faster than active dry yeast while achieving the same leavening results. It is milled into finer granules and is guaranteed to be 100 percent active from the start. It can be mixed directly into the dry ingredients. No proofing first. It is also more stable with a longer shelf life. If stored frozen in an airtight container, instant yeast can last for years.
For ease of use, faster activation, stability, and shelf life, its the form we use at BAKE! and what we recommend for home bakers. The recipes in Zingermans Bakehouse and Celebrate Every Day, and those we teach at BAKE!, are written for instant yeast. The brand we use consistently is Saf instant Red, manufactured for Lesaffre, the largest producer of commercial yeast in the world.
There are faster acting instant yeasts such as RapidRise, Bread Machine, and Quick Rise. They are stable and simple to use but formulated to activate fermentation more quickly. They are not suited for dough recipes that require a long slow rise or cold proofing. We use traditional methods. In fermentation this means using time to develop flavor. We prefer less yeast and more time. Long fermentation often leads to bread that feels easier to digest.
Conversions can be confusing. A useful rule of thumb is this. Use half the weight of fresh yeast when converting to active dry, and a third of the weight of fresh when converting to instant. If fresh yeast is 100 percent, active dry is 50 percent and instant is 33 percent. If using active dry instead of instant, use one and a half times the amount.
Every form of Bakers yeast is the same plant based, one cell fungus. Fresh, Active Dry, or Instant. They are processed differently and the amount in the dough must be adjusted. Bakers yeast cells perform fermentation by consuming sugars and starches in dough and producing carbon dioxide, ethanol, and acids. That process gives dough its rise. It is steady work. So is baking.
As home bakers, we manage the amount of yeast and the temperature of the dough to get good results. Dorothy Hartley in Food in England lists Brewers Yeast, Dry yeast, Potato yeast, German yeast, and Modern yeast. Humanity learned to turn wheat into nourishing food by allowing long fermentation. Not rushing it. Letting time work quietly.
Whether you choose fresh, active dry, or instant, understanding how each behaves in dough makes the process less awkward. The goal is not speed alone. It is flavor, structure, and a rise that feels earned. And if the loaf collapses once or twice, that has happened here too.